Methodology
Channel Considerations
Channel-Specific Modeling Considerations
Different advertising channels require specific modeling approaches due to their unique characteristics, infrastructure, and consumption patterns. This document outlines the modeling considerations for Linear TV and Digital Out-of-Home (DOOH) channels, which share some common elements but also have distinct measurement requirements.Linear TV
Definition and Scope
We classify Linear TV as content that is transmitted via traditional broadcasting methods and follows a predetermined programming schedule.| Broadcast distribution type | Equipment involved |
|---|---|
| Over-the-air (OTA) & Digital Terrestrial Television (DTT) | Transmitting towers, repeaters, household antennas… |
| Cable | Same as the Internet network (infrastructure is typically shared across telephone, television and Internet) |
| Satellite | Transmitting Satellite dishes, Satellite, Receiving satellite dishes, set top boxes |
| Internet Powered Television (IPTV) | Internet network, set top boxes |
Boundaries of Measurement
The Scope3 Linear TV model focuses on estimating emissions coming from the distribution (broadcasting) and consumer viewing of television content and advertising.| Lifecycle Category | Emissions Source | Status | Includes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Media Production | Content production | Not Included | |
| Creative Production | Ad production | Not included | |
| Media Distribution | Corporate emissions from TV network | Included | See Corporate Emissions |
| Media & Creative Distribution | Broadcast Signal preparation, transmission & reception | Included | Encoding & multiplexing OTA/DTT, cable, Satellite & IPTV networks (use phase & embodied) Household Equipment used for signal reception (use phase & embodied) |
| Media & Creative Consumer Device | TV viewing | Included | Television device (use phase & embodied) |
Emissions Calculation Methodology
Corporate Emissions
See Corporate EmissionsBroadcast Signal Emissions
Encoding & Multiplexing
In A comparison of the carbon footprint of digital terrestrial television with video-on-demand the BBC estimated that their encoding & multiplexing facility required a power draw of 400kW to encode TV content for their 24 channels. We use this estimate to derive that it takes an average power draw of 16.7kW to encode and multiplex TV content for one channel (no matter the number of viewing households). For TV networks and/or channels where actual power usage data is available, we use those values instead of the average.Signal Transmission
Energy Use
For each TV broadcast distribution method we consider a fixed energy consumption required to broadcast the signal no matter the number of viewing households. Different TV broadcast distribution methods have varying power efficiency in different countries but for now we do not differentiate between countries. For each TV distribution method we have derived power draw estimates from annual energy consumption, either from primary sourced energy consumption data shared with Scope3 by network operators or from the BBC paper.| TV Distribution Method | Energy consuming sources | Required Power for signal transmission of 1 TV channel | Source(s) | Assumptions |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| OTA/DTT | Over the air transmission network | 165 kW | Terrestrial Network operators | - National distribution |
| Cable | Cable network | 16 kW | BBC paper | - TV represents 53% of cable network usage - The Virgin Media cable network provider in the UK hosts 400 channels. |
| Satellite | Uplink transmission from TV station tower to satellite | 3.15kW | BBC paper | - No emissions coming from downlink transmission from space satellite to household dishes (satellites being powered by the sun) - Assuming equal energy usage across all BBC’s 24 channels |
Embodied Emissions
In the absence of data specific to each TV distribution method, we utilize our estimates of the embodied emissions as the fixed Internet network (0.00000443 gCO2e per kb) to derive the embodied emissions of each distribution method per second, assuming 6Mbps per transmitter per channel, across 1000 transmitters.Distribution Method Usage
The prevalence of each TV distribution method varies by TV network and geographically. For example, in France OTA/DTT and IPTV are the most widely used distribution methods in terms of households, whereas in Germany satellite is the most prevalent method. We apply a country-specific ratio of distribution methods for major markets, and use a global average for other countries.| Country | % of households using OTA/DTT | % of households using cable | % of households using satellite | % of households using IPTV |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Global Defaults | 26% | 29% | 20% | 25% |
| USA | 19% | 43% | 17% | 21% |
| UK | 41% | 9% | 23% | 27% |
| France | 46% | 0% | 8% | 46% |
| Germany | 3% | 42% | 46% | 9% |
| Australia | 48% | 0% | 8% | 44% |
Household Equipment Emissions
Energy Consumption
We consider some household equipment “passive”, meaning that they do not require any power to receive the broadcast signal, and others “active”.| Component | Broadcasting Method(s) | Global % of household with that equipment for that distribution method | Active or Passive | Estimated Power Draw | Source(s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Household antena | OTA/DTT | 100% | Passive | 0W | - |
| Satellite dish | Satellite | 100% | Passive | 0W | - |
| Low-Noise Block Downconverter (LNB) | Satellite | 100% | Active | 5W | Average across various manufacturers’ specifications |
| Signal Amplifier | OTA/DTT & Satellite | 20% | Active | 5W | BBC paper |
| Decoder / STB | Cable, Satellite & IPTV | 100% | Active | 16W | BBC paper |
| Co-axial cable | Cable & IPTV | 100% | Passive | 0W | - |
| Home router | IPTV | 100% | Active | 5W | See Data Transfer |
Embodied Emissions
Similarly to how we model consumer devices (see Consumer Devices), we estimate Production Energy per Use Second (PEPS) for each and every piece of household equipment.| Component | Broadcasting Method(s) | Global % of household with that equipment for that distribution method | Lifetime Impact kgCO2e (excluding use) | Usage (h/day) | Years in use | PEPS (gCO2e/s) | Source(s) | Mass (grams) | Example Units |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Household antena | OTA/DTT | 100% | 127 | 3.9 | 10 | 0.002484788742 | 860 | Clearstream 2MAX HDTV Antenna | |
| Satellite dish | Satellite | 100% | 592 | 3.9 | 10 | 0.01155715694 | 4000 | Cahors SMC65 White Fibreglass Satellite Dish | |
| Low-Noise Block Downconverter (LNB) | Satellite | 100% | 37 | 3.9 | 5 | 0.001444644617 | 250 | Universal 0.1dB Satellite LNB | |
| Signal Amplifier | OTA/DTT & Satellite | 20% | 59 | 3.9 | 10 | 0.001155715694 | 400 | Antenna Signal Amplifier | |
| Decoder / STB | Cable, Satellite & IPTV | 100% | 265 | 3.9 | 5 | 0.01034365546 | 1790 | Technisat Technicorder ISIO SC | |
| Co-axial cable | Cable & IPTV | 100% | 18 | 3.9 | 10 | 0.0003467147082 | 120 | CIMPLE CO Coaxial Cable | |
| Home router | IPTV | 100% | 45.9 | 24 | 5 | 0.0002910958904 | 310 | Fritz!Box 7530 |
Summary
| Broadcast Distribution Method | Variable Power per viewing device | PEPs (gCO2e/s) |
|---|---|---|
| OTA/DTT | 1W | 0.0036 |
| Cable | 16W | 0.0107 |
| Satellite | 22W | 0.0230 |
| IPTV | 21W | 0.0107 |
TV Viewing Emissions
We follow the same methodology as described in Consumer Devices, accounting for both use phase (energy consumption) and embodied emission (production & disposal). We adapt the “synthetic TV system” for Linear TV accordingly:- we don’t include set-top-boxes (STBs) or decoders as they are already accounted for as part of household equipment required for TV content and ad distribution.
- we keep the assumption from Urban et Al that 7% of televisions come with a sound bar.
| Device | Power (W) | PEPS (gCO2e/s) |
|---|---|---|
| TV System (Linear TV) | 75 | 0.0096 |
Impression Calculation
If TV impressions are not provided as model input, but unique reach and average frequency are, we assume a co-viewing factor of 1.5 to estimate the number of televisions - aligning with published ranges from TV audience measurement organizations across major markets.Digital Out-of-Home (DOOH)
Definition and Scope
Digital Out-of-Home (DOOH) refers to digital displays used for advertising in public spaces, such as billboards, transit displays, and retail screens. Unlike Linear TV, DOOH screens are owned or leased by media owners who have direct control over their operation and maintenance.Boundaries of Measurement
DOOH screens, like consumer devices, require energy to display an ad. Energy consumption during the use phase is in fact the highest source of emissions. However, on the contrary to consumer devices, billboards are owned or leased by media owners who therefore have a high level of operational control over the screen attributes that influence embodied and energy related emissions (venue category, manufacturer, model, size, location and positioning, operating hours, brightness settings etc…). For that reason, we are including emissions from screens’ energy usage and production to “media distribution”.| Emissions source | Lifecycle category | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Screens’ embodied emissions | Media Distribution | In-development |
| Screens’ energy consumption | Media Distribution | Included |
| Corporate emissions | Media Distribution | Included |
| Use of Ad Technology | Ad Selection | In-development |
| Creative data transfers | Creative Distribution | Included |
| Screens’ recycling/disposal | Disposal | To be considered |
Emissions Calculation Methodology
Screen Emissions
Embodied Emissions
Coming soonEnergy Consumption
On the contrary to consumer device emissions, we have found no credible research paper describing the power draw of large digital billboards. As such, we estimate for individual screens based on a variety of input data sources (listed in order from most accurate to least accurate):- Electricity metres installed on the screens themselves and monitoring power draw in near real-time.
- Power bills received by media owners on a monthly, quaterly or yearly basis, for a group of or for individual screens.
- Technical specifications from screen manufacturers like Daktronics, Samsung or Panasonic. We have found that these often document maximum power draw (instead of average power draw), which can lead to an over-estimation of energy consumption.
- Extrapolation based on physical dimensions and one of the above data point for screens from the same media owner.
- Extrapolation based on physical dimensions and venue type, off the back of data for 500k+ screens kindly provided to us by early partners (including DOOH programmatic platform Hivestack and DOOH media owners JCDecaux ANZ, Go Media and Lumo).